| TEAM / ROUND | ROUND 1 | ROUND 2 | ROUND 2A | ROUND 3 | ROUND 3A | ROUND 4 | ROUND 4A | ROUND 5 | ROUND 6 |
| ARIZONA | Mark Prior | Jason Simontacchi | Ryan Franklin | John McDonald | Travis Driskill | Tom Wilson | Clay Condrey | ||
| DETROIT | Austin Kearns | NYY Drew Henson | Michael Tejera | Peter Munro | NYY Trey Hodges | Tony Fiore | Shawn Sedlacek | ||
| N.Y. METS | Eric Hinske | Francisco Rodriguez | Franklyn German | Francis Beltran | Colby Lewis | Scott Cassidy | Andres Torres | ||
| BOSTON | Sean Burroughs | LAN Chris Snelling | STL Pete Walker | CIN Freddy Sanchez | TAM Ben Broussard | BAL Mike Kinkade | BAL Mike Koplove | ||
| CHICAGO | NYM Victor Martinez | CIN Kevin Mench | TAM Jorge Sosa | TAM Runelvys Hernandez | TAM Willie Bloomquist | TAM Carlos Silva | Kit Pellow | ||
| N.Y. YANKEES | Hank Blalock | DET Kazuhisa Ishii | Jayson Werth | DET Miguel Asencio | DET Darrell May | DET Ken Huckaby | Earl Snyder | ||
| ATLANTA | PHI Joe Borchard | Dewon Brazelton | Rod Barajas | Joe Roa | Joe Lawrence | Marcus Thames | Juan Diaz | ||
| TEXAS | BAL Jake Peavy | CIN Miguel Olivo | CIN Justin Wayne | MIL Josh Bard | CIN Ben Kozlowski | CIN Jeremy Hill | NYM Aaron Taylor | ||
| TAMPA BAY | John Lackey | Kirk Saarloos | Endy Chavez | Justin Miller | Reggie Taylor | Mike Bacsik | CHI Matt Cepicky | ||
| PITTSBURGH | Bret Myers | Jason Lane | Joe Thurston | Luis Pineda | CIN Brendan Donnelly | CHI Brandon Berger | MIN Salomon Torres | ||
| LOS ANGELES | Brandon Phillips | John Patterson | MIN Wily Moe Pena | STL John Stephens | Mike Bynum | SFO Vance Wilson | Luke Hudson | ||
| SAN DIEGO | CIN Rodrigo Lopez | CIN Damaso Marte | CIN Mike Crudale | CIN Matt Franco | CIN Zach Day | CIN Erik Bedard | CIN Mike Ryan | ||
| TORONTO | Josh Fogg | Alex Sanchez | CIN Trevor Hafner | Orlando Merced | Andy Van Hekken | Jaime Cerda | Corey Thurman | ||
| FLORIDA | Hee Seop Choi | Ricardo Rodriguez | Jung Bong | Steve Bechler | Luke Allen | Ben Howard | Mike Smith | ||
| SEATTLE (tie) | MIL Bobby Hill | LAN Chin-Feng Chen | MIL Darren Holmes | LAN Tony Torcato | LAN Pat Strange | LAN Jason Hart | LAN David Ross | ||
| ANAHEIM (tie) | Jon Rauch | Rafael Soriano | MIN Ben Diggins | Tony Alvarez | Bill Hall | Rick Bauer | Alex Herrera | ||
| PHILADELPHIA | ATL Orlando Hudson | Geronimo Gil | Covelli Crisp | J.J. Davis | Alfredo Amezaga | Ricky Stone | Jesse Orosco | ||
| SAN FRANCISCO | FLA Carl Crawford | FLA Ryan Jensen | STL Joey Eischen | STL Brian Tallet | STL Jason Standridge | STL Steve Smyth | |||
| MINNESOTA | ANA Marlon Byrd | STL Aaron Cook | LAN Abraham Nunez | Ed Rogers | TAM Tim Drew | Wilken Ruan | |||
| OAKLAND | Jorge Julio | Mike Maroth | Yorvit Torrealba | Jason Michaels | Raul Gonzalez | CHI Josh Pearce | |||
| BALTIMORE | MIL Oliver Perez | LAN Alexis Gomez | CHI Brandon Larson | Esteban German | Scott Shields | Jae Seo | |||
| CINCINNATI | CHI Morgan Ensberg | Cliff Lee | STL Jeremy Affeldt | Jason Romano | BAL Corky Miller | Jason Davis | |||
| KANSAS CITY | Aaron Harang | Chris Hammond | Kevin Cash | Jamey Carroll | John Ennis | Brandon Villafuerte | |||
| ST. LOUIS | Mark Ellis | MIL Omar Infante | Jayson Durocher | Ryan Ludwick | Jamie Walker | Dan Smith | |||
| CLEVELAND | Dennis Tankersley | STL Ramon Santiago | STL Brad Lidge | TAM Sun-Woo Kim | CIN Chone Figgins | STL Julius Matos | |||
| MILWAUKEE | STL Mike Restovich | Ty Wigginton | Mark Hendrickson | BAL Eric Cyr | Chad Zerbe | Eduardo Perez | |||