Fast-paced and captivating, My Brothers' Keeper paints an accurately grim picture of the Civil War, focuses on the human cost and impact of war, and brings a personal connection to a time in history often reduced to statistics, biographies of famous generals, and battlefield names (grades 5 - 8).
Iowa Reading Journal

In her new book for 9- to 12-year-olds, Nancy Johnson keeps this notion well in her mind. "My Brother's Keeper," her short saga of coming of age during the Civil War has believable, interesting characters in a historically accurate setting. It sets a good pace and holds the attention of readers who are well into adulthood.
--William David Barry, Books, Maine Sunday Telegram, March 29, 1998

The story unfolds in a tight narrative that will hold readers' interest, and Josh's character development is both believable and touching. Historical details are accurate; anyone who has visited Civil War battle sites will find the experiences at Little Round Top and The Wilderness as convincing as they are exciting.
Starr E. Smith, School Library Journal

Joshua's bravery despite his fears makes him a fascinating character and this novel a wonderful tale of brotherly love and of the hardships of war.
Rebecca Joseph, Children's Literature, June 1998