For "
Harry the Crow
":
"The twelfth issue of Aeon Speculative Fiction
contains a range of agreeable stories,
of which the best are "Harry the Crow"
by John Kratman and "Moonlight on the
Carpet" by David Levine. In "Harry the Crow",
a near-future Native American tribe still
follows the old ways of establishing proper
manhood and warriorhood, and a member of
the lodge becomes determined to initiate his
construct, a robot friend, among the elect.
This happens in first humorous and then
dangerous ways, amounting in the end to a
cunningly revisionist tall tale."
--Nick Gevers in
Locus
"The humor is funny and the characters
believable...'Harry the Crow' doesn’t end with
a droll punch line but with a chilling realization
that says something important about what it
might mean to be human. Very enjoyable."
--Marshall Payne in
The Fix
.
For "
Old Folks' Home
":
"Here's a good idea– a retirement home in space...A light piece of story,
on the heartwarming side."
--Lois Tilton in
The Internet Review of Science Fiction.
For "
Churel
":
"Mutiny and murder come to life in this exotic monster story."
--Michele Lee at her
Booklove blog.
"The story is well told, with excellent pacing, flashes of local detail that
enhance the verisimilitude, a hero we can care about and a monster that
is a little bit out of the ordinary, though no less fearsome for that."
--Peter Tenannt at
Web Whisperin'
.
For "
Nanuq
":
"
'Nanuq' is a nice survival tale with compelling characters.
"
--Aimee Poynter at
Tangent Online