Humes biggest contribution to
philosophy was his attack on the foundation of knowledge itself.
By questioning the basis upon which we draw conclusions about the
world from experience, he demonstrated how weak this foundation really
is. For example, we assume that events relate to each other
as in a cause and an effect such as one billiard ball hitting another
and causing the other ball to move. However, all we really see
is one ball move and then the other ball move. We infer that
one caused the other yet we never see the cause. We have no
basis to infer that the second ball must move because the first one
hit it. In fact, we just assume the two are related because
we have seen the events happen together so many times. In fact,
whenever we see two things happen closely together, the human mind
associates them as a cause and effect but this is unwarranted.
The attack on induction gets worse. First, we make a number
of observations of nature such as a dropped object falling to the
ground. Second, we see this many times. We conclude that a released
object will always fall to the ground. However, there is a built
in assumption which is that nature is uniform or will behave uniformly.
If this is true, then we can conclude that past events will be repeated
in the future, i.e. a released object will fall. However, we have
no basis to prove nature is uniform. Therefore, we have no basis
upon which to believe that a released object will fall to the ground.
Worse, all inductive arguments have this flaw. We do this
from what Hume calls "sentiments" or just a habit of mind.
Many
attacks on Hume's arguments have been made but none decisively answer
this problem. In my opinion, this argument should not be seen
so much as the defeat of philosophy or reason but a boundary on absolute
knowledge. We cannot get through the day without induction based
on experience. Even Hume had to do this and in the end, we survive
with this approach. However, we must accept that we can only
get probable answers in this manner, not foolproof answers.