<%@LANGUAGE="VBSCRIPT" CODEPAGE="1252"%> 14Mar04_sdei

The Teachers' Education Institute


Contact: Dr. David L. Mollet  tel/fax (619) 463-1270   email: tei@cox.net
6656 Reservoir Lane, San Diego, CA 92115



Why Kush should be taught to every grade 6 student

The presentation has been given at various conferences and workshops inluding different conferences of the California Council of Social Studies; the Los Angeles Center for International Studies; and the Conference of the National Alliance of Black School Educators.

Let me begin by posing some questions.

1. How many of our students, when they study the ancient cultures of Mesopotamia, Egypt or Greece, are aware that at the same time as these civilizations existed another major civilization thrived in the interior of Africa? That at the time of the Minoan and Mycenaean cultures of Greece, the pre-Aryan cities of India, and the Sumerian cities of Mesopotamia there was a major civilization in the interior of Africa.

2. How many students would be aware that the 25th Dynasty in Egypt was a Dynasty of Kings from an African culture south of Egypt?

3. How many students would be aware that a Roman army at the time of the Emperor Augustus was challenged and defeated by an African army led by a strong and powerful queen?

4. And let me ask you this last question. How many girls in our classes, when learning about the mighty Roman Emperors, the great pharaohs of Egypt, and the male leaders and decision makers of Greece, are also aware of the female leadership of an African civilization? That through all of these periods a civilization existed that was ruled, for some of the time, by powerful queens.

If the answer to these questions is, "not many, if any at all," then it is time to bring the ancient civilization of Kush into the middle grade curriculum.

The presentation is divided into three parts.
1. Brief Overview
A brief overview of the civilization we call Kush. The last page of this presentation will provide you with a bibliography of references for a more in-depth study.
2. All students should study Kush
Suggest some reasons why it is important that all students are exposed to this culture.
3. Pointers in Teaching Kush
A. Initial introduction to Kush (Aida).
B. Hairbraiding - Linking past and present.
C. Relevance of storytelling

1. Brief Overview
Let me first deal with two questions:
Where was Kush located? and
Where was Kush in terms of time?

Location
The area we know as Kush was located in the southern part of modern Egypt and the northern part of Sudan (north of Khartoum). The size of the kingdom changed throughout its history. At one time it occupied a small area south of the fourth cataract of the Nile. At another time, it extended from just north of modern day Khartoum to the Mediterranean Sea, making it the largest empire ever known along the Nile.

. Aida

Throughout history Kush has been known by different names.
Nubia
Ancient Nubia lay south of Egypt. Its northern boundary was near the town of Aswan and it southern border near Khartoum. It encompassed the River Nile both in its eastern "bulge" and its western "bulge". Part of Ancient Nubia lay in modern day Egypt and part in Sudan.
Kush
Nubia, like Egypt, is referred to as Upper Nubia and Lower Nubia; Upper Nubia being nearer the source of the River Nile, and Lower Nubia sharing a border with Egypt. In 1900 B.C.E., an inscription mentioned the name Kush and after 1550 B.C.E. the Egyptians began to use the name Kush to refer to Upper Nubia.
Ethiopia

When the name Ethiopia is used in ancient texts this does not refer to present day Ethiopia. Ethiopia is a Greek word and comes from the Greek word aethiops. Translated, the name Ethiopia means "land of the burnt faces." The Greeks and Romans used this name for the land south of Egypt.

Examples of African monarchs from Nubia/Kush/Ethiopia
Taharqa
Taharqa came to the throne of Kush at a very early age. At sixteen he led his armies against the invading Assyrians and this action is recorded in the Bible. Later, he rules the largest empire in ancient Africa. It extended north to the Mediterranean Sea and included Egypt and the whole of the Sudan.
Nefertari
She was one of many great Nubian queens. Her marriage to Rameses II, who was one of the last great Egyptian pharaohs, brought the fighting between Egypt and Kush to an end. The marriage was a political arrangement between the two rulers but it later grew into one of the greatest royal love affairs in history.
Tiye - Kushite Queen of Egypt
Tiye was a Kushite living at the time when Kush was a colonial dominion of Egypt. The Kushites, a proud black people, maintained a strong cultural and political identity during this time of Egyptian occupation. Amenhotep III, captivated by Tiye's beauty and intellect, defied the priests and married her although she was a commoner. Their son was one of the most famous pharaohs, Tutankhamen.

Top (The presentation is divided into three parts)

Time

Egyptianization

Girl

Hieroglyphs

JebelGuidedReading

Top (The presentation is divided into three parts)

2. All students should study Kush
Six Reasons why it is important that all students learn about Kush.
1. An Erroneous Message
2. The Female Role in Kush
3. Ruled by Queens
4. Queens of Kush

5. Understanding Concepts: Acculturation
6. A Challenge for the Future

1. An Erroneous Message
Many people are concerned with the fact that many African-American students first encounter people from their ethnic historical background when studying the era of slavery. I would suggest that as well as studying this era it is very important to introduce all students to ancient societies from the interior of Africa.

If we neglect to do this then we indicate to our students that nothing of importance happened historically in the interior of Africa B.C.E. and that Africa had no early civilization as did the rest of the world. Some teachers recognize this and introduce civilizations from the interior of Africa during a study of the Middle Ages. They study the civilizations of Ghana and Mali. However, a curriculum that neglects to include Kush as one of the major ancient civilizations suggests to students that Africa had no ancient civilizations as did the rest of the world.

Without this inclusion students are left with the impression that the first civilizations of B.C.E. were all located around the Mediterranean, or in India and China. They are unaware that a civilization, equal to those, thrived in the African continent and that features we look for in a civilization were all present in Kush. They were present in the Kerma society of c.2500 B.C.E.; the Napatan Period, c.1070 B.C.E. and the Meroitic period, c.300 B.C.E.

2. The Female Role in Kush
It is particularly important that girls study Kush in their middle grades history curriculum. For the most part, when they study other ancient civilizations they come into contact with societies where leadership roles and decision making were in the hands of the men of the society. Only on very few occasions are they able to identify with those in society or those who have played an influential role.

The study of Kush enables girls to study a society where women took on roles of leadership, a society where women were highly respected and help positions of power alongside men. For example, a queen in Kush was portrayed in art as of equal size to the king. Compare this to Egypt where the queen was portrayed in art as much smaller than the king indicating comparative importance

. KermaSAS

Top (2. All students should study Kush)

3. Ruled by Queens
Furthermore, Kush during part of its history, was ruled by strong and powerful queens, and it was a queen that led the Kushite revolt against the injustice of Roman rule and the imposition of Roman taxation on the Kushite economy.

Some time back I was at the British Museum in London I stood before the beautifully sculpted head of Augustus, the very one that Candace Amanirenas, Queen of Kush removed from a life size statue when her army plundered the city of Aswan. The very same sculpture she took back to Meroe and buried in the sand at the palace entrance so that it would lie beneath the sole of her foot each time she entered or left the palace. (Similar symbolic gestures were found on the soles of Tutankhamen's sandals. Figures depicting his enemies were embossed in the leather of the soles.)

Admiring the features of Augustus we wondered how many African-American students would be aware of the link between this famous artifact and a queen from their ethnic historical background. We do not have a likeness of Candace Amanirenas but we do know that she would be similar in appearance to this Kushite queen whose likeness was found carved on the walls of a temple in Kush.

4. Queens of Kush
Queens of Kush were full figured African women. Kushites saw their beauty, wealth and power reflected in the large size of their queens. These rulers were very elegant, using make up in a similar manner to their neighbors, the Egyptians, paying special attention to their eye make up. This elegance also showed itself in their long manicured nails. The Kushites believed that long and beautiful nails were an indication that the person was rich and powerful enough never to do any manual work.

5. Understanding Concepts: Acculturation
There are also other reasons why it is important to study Kush. The study of Kush gives teachers the ideal opportunity to teach a number of concepts; concepts and themes that are important goals in our social studies curriculum. Let us look at one example. Students need to understand the historical concepts of cultural diffusion and acculturation. The relationship between Egypt and Kush gives the ideal opportunity to learn about these concepts. However, in order to use these two cultures as examples or illustrative material students need to have a sound knowledge of both societies.

The period 1550-1070 B.C.E. is ideal material for this. Egypt had conquered the Kerma society of Kush and the New Kingdom pharaohs used a policy of Egyptianizing Kush in order to keep control of the Kushite people. We can give students an experience of this period if we guide them to stand in the shoes of a Kushite boy, leaving his home to live and receive an education at the court of the Egyptian pharaoh. He then returns as as adult to take up a position of power in Kush, brining back to Kush the Egyptian customs, manners, fashion, etc., that he learned at the Egyptian court. Students are thus well prepared for understanding, at first hand, the idea of acculturation.

Furthermore in studying this period of both Egyptian and Kushite history, students have an opportunity of understanding cultural diffusion and acculturation used as a planned policy of how one society can control another. The Egyptianization of Kush is, therefore, a clear example of acculturation. This example of acculturation can be compared with the experience of different cultures settling in America today. The process of the Egyptianization of Kush went on for 500 years.

MapKush

Top (2. All students should study Kush)

6. A Challenge for the Future
During my visit to the British Museum I also admired the many examples of Meroitic script and were able to examine closely this intriguing script that was left behind on temple walls in Kush. A unique script for a long forgotten language. There is a wealth of written material available but as yet the meaning remains a mystery to us, for no one has cracked the code.

Not so long ago historians faced a similar challenge with Egyptian hieroglyphs. Champollion, whom we credit for deciphering Egyptian hieroglyphs, first took up the challenge when still a boy. Learning that the picture writing on temple walls and on ancient papyrus in Egypt was a complete mystery to the modern world, he vowed that one day he would crack the code. As teachers we know only too well the importance of sowing rich seeds of knowledge and inquiry at receptive times in a student's life.

Today, a similar situation exists in the archaeological discoveries of Ancient Kush. Are there students in our classrooms today who will be inspired by an exciting presentation of Kushite history to the point where they will vow that one day they will take up the challenge and make a lasting contribution in this field?

Selected Bibliography
Anne M. Jennings, The Nubians of West Aswan (Colorado: Lynne Rienner, 1995)
Basil Davidson, African Kingdoms (New York: Time-Life Books, 1966)
Calliope, Ancient Nubia (Nov/Dec)
Derek A. Welsby, The Kingdom of Kush: the Napatan and Meroitic Empires (Princeton, N.J.: Markus Wiener, 1998)
John H. Taylor, Egypt and Nubia (London: Published for the trustees of the British Museum by British Museum Press, 1991)
Joyce and David Mollet, Ancient Civilizations: Egypt (San Diego: W. Education Resources, 1997)
Joyce and David Mollet, Ancient Civilizations: Kush (San Diego: W. Education Resources, 1997)
P. L. Shinnie, Ancient Nubia (London: New York: Kegan Paul International, 1996)
Special Publications Division, National Geographic Society, Splendors of the Past (Washington, D.C.: National Geographic Society, 1981)
Stanley Burstein (Ed.), Ancient African Civilizations: Kush and Axum (Princeton, N.J.: Markus Wiener, 1998)
Strabo, The Geography of Strabo, Volume III , Translated by Hamilton and Falconer (London: G. Bell & Sons, 18898)
Timothy Kendall, Kerma and the Kingdom of Kush, 2500-1500 B.C.: The archaeological discovery of an ancient Nubian empire (Washington, D.C.: National Museum of African Art, Smithsonian Institution, 1997)
William Yewdale Adams, Nubia: Corridor to Africa (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1977)

Top (2. All students should study Kush)

3. Pointers in Teaching Kush
We have so far concentrated on the importance of teaching the subject matter of Kush to all students but particularly African-American students. I'll close this presentation by saying something about the methodology that I would recommend and through which this content should be taught. I'll cover:
A. Initial introduction to Kush (Aida).
B. Hairbraiding - Linking past and present.
C. Relevance of storytelling.

A. Initial introduction to Kush.
We are very fortunate that we have an excellent introduction to Kush through the opera Aida. You will find below the story of the opera. One way would be to read the story, spend a little time discussing what happened, and then ask some questions (see below). Some excerpts from the opera could then be played.

Moment2

The following questions will lead students into a study of Kush.
1. Where did the slave girl come from?
2. Who was she and who was her father?
3. Which two countries were at war?
4. What do we know about the pharaohs in Egypt?
5. What do we know about the country referred to as Ancient Ethiopia?
6. What might Aida have looked like?

B. Hairbraiding - Linking past and present.
Another way in which we can link past and present is through hairbraiding.

Mummy Queen StoryJebelBarkal StoryKerma

The students can be shown the picture of the modern day Sudanese girl and told that Aida would have probably looked similar. Her hairstyle could then be discussed and compared with the hairstyle found on the mummy of Queen Nedjmet (1070-946 B.C.E.) suggesting that young girls in Ancient Nubia braided their hair in much the same way as girls in modern day Sudan, and also in modern day America.

C. Relevance of storytelling.
Storytelling is something which is common to all cultures. As a mode for transmitting knowledge it has been used from the beginning of man's cultural development, and was a powerful tool for understanding. Stories, more than any other mode, allow students to view events from a perspective other than their own. A story, by appealing to the imagination, transports the listener back into the historical event.

It allows those events to be seen through the eyes and experiences of people from the past. In comparison, information on a printed page is a poor second when attempting to transmit the richness and vitality of the event. In doing all this the narrative approach will awaken in students a fascination for the past. By appealing to the imagination, students can be introduced to a wealth of ideas, experiences, perceptions and thoughts. The next step of nurturing skills in the methodology of history will then become much easier, and hopefully a comparatively painless task.

Two Examples
The first page of a story Letter Intercepted . This imaginary account is based on fact. Knowledge of the intercepted letter comes from a stele found in the temple of Karnak in 1954. It appears that this was the second of two stelae that describe Kamose's war against the Hyksos. The other stele is known from a few broken fragments, and a hieratic copy known as the Carnarvon Tablet.

Sudan

The following is one example showing how different student activities can be created as assignments for students. If appropriate and necessary such assignments can be used for assessment purposes.

Timeline1

Top (2. All students should study Kush)

This story (see below for page 1 of the story) deals with two main threads at the same time, the process of archaeology, and the knowledge of Kushite life that can be gleaned from this particular archaeological excavation. Students should be encouraged to recognize these two main concepts. One main activity for the students is to get them to generalize from given story content. For example, students can be asked to choose quotations from the story that best illustrate that:
a) Timothy Kendall is a dedicated, enthusiastic and skilled archaeologist;
b) religion was an important part of King Taharqa's life;
c) the Kushites believed that the rock formation at Jebel Barkal was far more than an accident of nature;
d) religion played an important role in the everyday life of the Kushites.

Timeline2

Students can then work independently. The following is an example of how a Guided Reading sheet can be used to monitor and assess students' progress.

Women
Top (2. All students should study Kush)