Tue, 13 Nov 2001 05:43:06 

From: "Mary Smith" <carthage42@hotmail.com>

To: SHARP-L@rootsweb.com

Message-ID: <F133GYdRGy9tCx1Dy3r000105b8@hotmail.com>

Subject: [SHARP-L] William SHARPs of Patrick Co., Va.

Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed

 

 

Betty and Roberta:

 

Deeds and other records do indeed support the belief that the William SHARP who moved to Franklin Co., Tenn., ca 1811/12 was the William SHARP on the Patrick Co., Va., Land Tax Lists from 1791-1811.

 

In 1811 and 1812 John BURNETT and Thomas REAVES were taxed on land sold to them by SHARPs who were identified only by their surname in the Tax Records:

1811                John BURNETT --  860 acres from SHARP

1812                Thomas REAVES - 1000a from SHARP

                    John BURNETT --  860a from SHARP, 140a from SHARP

 

The deed to REAVES is from William SHARP, Sr.; I have a photocopy.  I haven't seen the deeds to BURNETT, but William SHARP Sr.'s sons, Richard and James, also disappear from the land tax records in 1811/1812.

 

The real problem comes with the other William SHARP(s).  Beginning in 1809 a William SHARP, Jr., appears on the tax list with 50 acres.  Although only in 1813 do the tax lists begin to specify where land is located, the 1808 deed from John HALL to William SHARP, Jr., indicates that the 50 acres was on Goblingtown Creek (the area where William SHARP Sr. owned most of his property.)  In 1810 and 1811 William Jr. is taxed on this land (plus 100 acres that he bought from Robert SHARP -- assuming that both these William SHARP Jrs. are the same person).  Then in 1811 William Jr. sold the 50 acres to William Sr., who we know was in the process of leaving Patrick Co., Va.,

for Franklin Co., Tenn.  Although at first glance this seems peculiar, William Sr. does in fact sell more land (1000a) to Thomas REAVES than he had been taxed on in the previous year (700a), and William Jr.'s Goblintown Creek property may have been included in the total.

 

Question: Was the William Jr. who sold the 50 acres the son of William Sr., and, if so, did he also emigrate from Patrick Co. ca 1811?  Or was he the William Jr. who continued to be taxed on the land he had bought from Robert SHARP?  It's possible that there were two William SHARP Jrs. in PCVA at the same time; one might have been slightly older than the other; and although they both might have owned land, it's also possible that only one did.  (If Roberta's William SHARP Jr. was born in 1790, he seems a little young to have purchased land in 1808.)

 

In any event we are left with one William SHARP, Jr., on the Patrick Co. Land Tax Lists.  In 1821 the tax lists start referring to him without

the "Jr.", although the 100 acres on the South Mayo River, located three miles from the Courthouse, would appear to be the same land that William Jr. had been taxed on earlier.

 

Then between 1827 and 1829 some real confusion occurs.  We go from land tax on WILLIAM SHARP --

1827           100a on waters of So. Mayo R., 3 mi. So. of Courthouse

                56a on waters of Russell's Cr.,4 mi. SW of Courthouse

to 1828          6 acres on Russell's Creek

 

In the same year Hiram ROGERS is taxed on 100 acres on Russell's Creek, which was transferred from William N. SHARP

 

In 1829 WILLIAM N. SHARP is taxed on:

              190 acres on headwaters of Russell's Creek (new grant),

                    5 mi. SW of Courthouse

                  (The only "new grant" I have found was in 1824 for

                    380 acres)

               56 acres on headwaters of Russell's Cr.,

                    5 mi. SW of Courthouse

   That same year Samuel GILBERT is taxed on 137 acres on the headwaters of Russell's Creek, which was transferred from William N. SHARP.  (The actual 1828 deed says the property lay "on the head waters of Russells Creek and South Mayo.")

 

The property sold to Hiram ROGERS is specified in the deed as part of a grant; this is not the case with that sold to GILBERT, although the land described in the deed sounds as though it may have been.

 

Is William SHARP the same person as William N. SHARP?  It sounds like it, but the pieces of land don't really add up either.

 

Roberta's work in tracing the different William SHARPs in Tenn. may help sort this out.  Roberta, have you found a marriage record for your couple in PCVA in 1817?  As we know, there was a marriage record for another William SHARP, Jr., in Patrick Co. -- that one to Philipena FITZGERALD in 1811

--

but that William appears to have been the William N. SHARP of the land tax records, who must have died ca. 1835/36 (if the fact that Philipena SHARP alone gave consent to the marriage of her daughter Luvenia in 1836 is any proof).  Although it may be only a coincidence, William N. SHARP disappears from the Patrick Co., Va., Land Tax Records in 1835.

 

The 200 acres of land which William N. SHARP sold to James DUVALL in 1832 was land on the headwaters of Russell's Creek, which SHARP had mortgaged in 1831 to secure a debt with the Danville Bank of Virginia. His securities for the bank debt were Samuel SHARP (whose relationship to William N. SHARP is still unclear to me), Harvey FITZGERALD, David HUDSON, and Zachariah TYLER. Harvey FITZGERALD was probably the father of William N. SHARP's wife Philipena.

 

Of course it's possible, though unlikely, that instead of dying in 1835, William N. SHARP left for Knox Co., Tenn., where he was later joined by Philipena.  He would have been about forty-nine or fifty years old at the time.  How old was the William SHARP in the 1850 Census for Knox Co., Tenn.?

  But whether that William SHARP was the same as William N. SHARP of Patrick Co., Va., from what Roberta reports he could not have been the son of William SHARP Sr.  There the evidence points to the William SHARP of Bedford Co., Tenn.

 

I gather from Roberta's message that Martin HANCOCK was a brother of Sarah HANCOCK, William SHARP Jr.'s wife.  A Martin HANCOCK appears in Patrick Co., Va., deeds, though not with any of the SHARPs.  Does the petition deal with land in Patrick Co., Va., or in Tenn.?

 

Mary

__________________________________________________________________________________

 

Tue, 13 Nov 2001 13:49:02 +0100

From: "Roberta Sharp" <rsharp@csupomona.edu>

To: SHARP-L@rootsweb.com

Message-Id: <v03110702b81604b4b760@[134.71.206.39]>

Subject: [SHARP-L] Heirs of James Sharp

Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"

 

 

To Betty and Mary,

 

>Does the petition deal with land in Patrick Co., Va., or in Tenn.?

 

The petition quoted from in the next paragraph has to do with assignment of the heirs of James Sharp of Franklin County, TN.  James and  his wife Mary had no children.  The petition clearly identifies William Sharp of Bedford County as a brother of James Sharp.  The photocopy I have of this document has been stamped "Project Preservation, Franklin County Loose Records, 118 High St. Courthouse Annex, Winchester, TN 37388," and there is in handwriting "1840-49-311."  Probably 1840-49 refers to a range of dates as James died in 1847.  I don't know what the 311 means unless perhaps a document number.  The deposition reads:

 

" To the Honorable A. J. Marchbanks, one of the circuit judges of Tennessee, presiding at Winchester.  Your petitioner Mary Sharp would respectfully represent unto your honor that James Sharp decd. a citizen of Franklin County in said State, departed this life about the ____ day of ____ 1847 leaving the following persons his only heirs & legal representatives to wit - your petitioner Mary, widow of said James - Richard Sharp Sr. & Robert Sharp citizens of said County & brothers to said James - William Sharp of Bedford County Tennessee brother of said James - James & Richard Lassater of Franklin County Tennessee and Robert Lassater of Coffee County children of Abner & Mary Lassater deceased, formerly Mary Sharp & sister to said James.

The children of Jesse Corn decd who died in Jackson County Alabama & who resided there - the numbers and names of whom are not known - said Jesse was the son of Wm & Mary Corn deceased, formerly Nancy Sharp & sister to said James, and the children of Cannon & Jemimah Moore...."

 

James' Sharp's estate was also the subject of a suit brought much later, 1869, by Nancy Hill vs. the heirs of James Sharp.  In this document, Thomas Finch. refers to William Sharp as "dead, & left several children but deponent knew but one, Wm H. Sharp."  I think it is important to keep in mind that this 1869 document was written approximately two decades later than the one above when memories of William Sharp had faded and the families had been split by civil war.  William's son Robert Martin Sharp was in Missouri by 1850 and dead by 1863.

 

>Roberta, have you found a marriage record for your couple in PCVA in 1817?

 

I did find the record in an index of Patrick County, Tennessee, at the Tennessee State Library. Unfortunately, I experienced the classic case of finding and an important item just at closing time and did not get to make a copy.  At the time I found it I was not certain it was the William I am researching as I had not yet seen the document quoted above.  I suppose that I should write for it as I live in California and have little chance of getting back to Nashville soon. 

Later the record  did show up on Worldconnect, and I printed that item.

 

>I gather from Roberta's message that Martin HANCOCK was a brother of Sarah HANCOCK, William SHARP Jr.'s wife.  A Martin HANCOCK appears in Patrick Co., Va., deeds, though not with any of the SHARPs.

 

Yes, Sarah Hancock was a daughter of Martin Hancock of Wilson County, Tennessee, so actually the Martin mentioned above would be Martin Hancock, Jr. Mary, if you have more detail on the Martin Sharp in Patrick Co., Va., such as the date of the deed, I would be interested to know about it.

 

Roberta   rsharp@csupomona.ed

_____________________________________________________________________________

 

Joy Q. Gallagher (GallagherJ@Cafe.net) found a loose Franklin Co., TN Chancery Court record styled "Nancy Hill et al vs J.W. Syler Admr & c Deposition of R.E. Lasater filed Nov. 15, 1873 T.H. Finch C & M." It was in the vertical files of the Franklin Co., TN Historical Society in the Franklin Co. Library. Here is the portion relating to the heirs of William Sharp:

 

........That the heirs of Wm. Sharp, an original heir, one of six original heirs of James Sharp dec.d are as follows.

1. Wm. H. Sharp in Texas

2. Eliza who intermarried with John Bell, who died, she afterward married _____ Downey.

3. Harriett who intermarried with James Keel, she is dead, & left 5 or 6 Heirs, names not known

4. Martin Sharp, residence unknown thought to be in California

5. Saml. Sharp, dead, not known whether he has left any family or not.

6. George Sharp, moved west, residence unknown, not known whether he left a family or not.

7. Henrietta, married ______ Hoover, dead, and left two children, Henrietta Hoover & other name unknown

 

R. E. Lasater

 

Sworn & Subscribed to

before me Novr. 15th 1873

T. H. Finch C & M

_____________________________________________________________________________

 

 

 

More About WILLIAM SHARP, JR.:

Residence: Abt. 1847, Bedford County, Tennessee

 

Notes for SARAH HANCOCK:

Several genealogists show Sallie as the first wife of William's. However, judging from an 1844 law suit brought by Ephraim Hunter against William, it might seem more likely that Sallie was his 2nd wife. There are a number of Hancock's mentioned as in-laws of William, and the fact that he married Penny in 1811, makes it more difficult to think that Sallie's in-laws (if they are) would be connected with a suit more than 30 years after Willima had remarried.

___________________________________________________________________

 

I keep finding more and more connections between William Sharp (m. Sarah Hancock) of Bedford County and the Franklin County Sharps.

For example,

the petition of heirs of William SHARP filed after the death of his son,

James SHARP  says in one place"William Sharp of Bedford County,

Tennessee-brother of said James Sharp, deceased."  Even stronger evidence

comes from Chancery Court Records of Bedford County, TN: Ephraim Hunter

[1843]   recovered a judgement against William Sharp and William Sharp, Jr.

. .  "Orator claims that Sharp pretented to sell property to Martin Hancock.  Martin and Samuel Hancock are the brothers in law of said

William Sharp, Sr.  The deed and witnessed by John Bell who is a son in law of William Sharp, Sr. and by William Sharpe, Jr. who is the son of William Sharp, Sr.  also, slaves were sold to James Sharp of Franklin Co., Tennessee" (p. 118).

 

I am still wondering  whether William and Jamima's son William married twice, first to a Penny Fitzgerald and second to Sarah Hancock. I think

they married about 1816, so William could have had a first marriage to Penny.  Did she die young?  So many young women did die from childbirth in those days.  I believe that most if not all of the children I named were children of  William and Sarah Hancock. Some of the names evidently come from the Hancock line;  Martin was the  given name of Sarah Hancock's father.

 

William of Bedford County was listed on the census as age 59 on the 1850 census, so he would have been born about 1790 or 1791, but the

difference between 1780 and 1790 could be a typo or transcription error. The William and Sarah Hancock Sharp whose children I named were living in Bedford County in 1850, but seem to have either died or moved soon after that.

What evidence specifically connects William Sharp of Knox County to the Franklin County Sharps?  When did he die?  We really need to sort out this dilemma by comparing specific evidence and determining whether we are talking about the same or different William Sharps.

 

Roberta   rsharp@csupomona.edu