Essentials
Born: 12 November 1820; Byron, Genesse County, New York
Son of: Samuel MERRILL and Phoebe ODELL
Married: 1. Cyrena DUSTIN; 20 September 1840; Nauvoo, Hancock, Illinois; 2. Mary Jane SMITH; 5 April 1851; Salt Lake City, Salt Lake, UT; 3. Rhoda Sylvia COLLETT; 9 October 1873; Salt Lake City, Salt Lake, UT
Died: 16 September 1904; Safford, Graham County, Arizona

Page contents
One-minute history
Story of Mary Jane Smith

BY DARYL JAMES
FROM 'JAMES/HATCH ONE MINUTE HISTORIES' (1994)
     Philemon Christopher Merrill went through the early hardships, persecutions and trials of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He was born Nov. 12, 1820, at Byron, Genesee County, N.Y., to Samuel Merrill and Phoebe Odell.
     At the age of 11 he accompanied his parents to Nauvoo, Ill., arriving in 1837. He was baptized into the Mormon Church in March 1839 and filled a mission to Wisconsin in 1840-41.
     On Sept. 20, 1840, he married Cyrena Dustin and went into housekeeping in Nauvoo. Philemon worked on the Temple which the Saints were trying hard to complete. He was closely associated with the Prophet Joseph Smith and tradition says he was one of the Prophet's bodyguards. Philemon helped evacuate Nauvoo when persecutors drove the Saints out, and he was one of the guards to cross the Mississippi River with Church records.
     Philemon enlisted as a volunteer in the Mormon Battalion and endured the long march to the Pacific

An undated photograph of Philemon C. Merrill, first stake patriarch in Safford, Ariz.

Coast. He left his wife and three children in Iowa to await his return. Once in California, Philemon stayed at headquarters in San Diego until the army discharged him in 1847. He then made his way back to Iowa to rejoin his family; however, Philemon never saw his youngest child again because she had died shortly after his enlistment. In the spring of 1849 the Merrills made ready and crossed the plains to Salt Lake Valley, arriving Oct. 16, 1849.
     With the permission of Cyrena, Philemon entered plural marriage April 5, 1851, with Mary Jane Smith. Then in June 1853 Philemon left to fill a mission for the Church to England until 1856. After his return, the Church called him to help settle parts of southern Idaho. The two families moved to Liberty, Idaho, near Bear Lake in 1869 and then to Soda Springs, Idaho. While at Liberty, Philemon married a third woman, Rhoda Sylvia Collett, on Oct. 9, 1873.
     In 1877 the Church called Philemon to help settle parts of central and southeastern Arizona. By then his second wife had died, so he took his two remaining families in August 1877 and headed for the San Pedro Valley.
     They had a great deal of faith, for the departure was with provisions only enough to last two days. The company made camp about one half mile south of the present town of St. David, Ariz., building a small stone fort of six or eight rooms. Philemon had first seen the area with the Mormon Battalion in 1847. It was here in 1878, while nearly all the settlers were suffering with chills and fever, that Erastus Snow set apart Philemon to preside over the Saints in the area. In 1881 Philemon asked that he be relieved of his responsibilities as Presiding Elder and left St. David in 1890, settling in Safford, Ariz.
     He later held the office of Patriarch, being ordained by John Henry Smith. Philemon was a good public speaker and loved to talk about the Prophet Joseph Smith. About 1900 he moved to San Jose, Ariz., and died at his home there Sept. 15, 1904, at the age of 84.

-- Sources: 1. Unpublished autobiography of Cyrena Dustin; 2. "Patriarchs: Philemon Christopher Merrill." The 25th Stake of Zion (On record at Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT).

Return to top

Story of Mary Jane Smith

The only surviving photograph of Mary Jane Smith.

AUTHOR UNKNOWN
FROM 'PIONEER WOMEN OF FAITH AND FORTITUDE'
VOLUME III, PP. 1,986 (1998)
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY, DAUGHTERS OF UTAH PIONEERS
     Mary Jane was born in Illinois in 1833. Not much is known of her childhood. An early Rhodes Scholar, she passed her love for books to her children. She lived for a time in the Mansion House with her mother, who later married Philo Dibble. She came to Utah probably between 1847 and 1850 with a wagon train, because at age 17 she married Philemon Christopher Merrill as a plural wife 5 April 1851. Her first child was born in Salt Lake City.
     The Merrills moved to Farmington, Davis County, where two more children joined the family. They next moved to Morgan, where Philemon helped build the railroad. There, Mary Jane's last five children were born. In 1869, the Merrills were on the move to settle Idaho. On this journey, according to the journal of Cyrena, Philemon's first wife, Mary Jane's life ended. Cyrena wrote of the move to Liberty, Bear Lake, Idaho in July 1869. "This was a hard trip for all of us, though it was only a hundred miles. Mary Jane's baby Herbert was only six weeks old, and Mary Jane was not strong." Cyrena continues, "I took little Lot in my wagon. He was just recovering from Typhoid Fever and was peevish and fretful, and I could do no more with him than anyone else." He would have been four years old, having been born in 1865. "We felt worn out when we reached our destination. We lived here only two years when, on June 2, 1871, Mary Jane died, leaving seven children, who now looked to me for a mother's care, the oldest being eighteen and the youngest only two years old." She finishes simply, "I prayfully undertook this charge."
     Only one photograph of Mary Jane survived. In it, she has a sober expression. Hers was a brief, hard, exciting life. She passed away at age 37, apparently buried "at the mouth of Emmigration Canyon, on the way to Liberty, in an unmarked grave." Other records indicate she passed away near Liberty, Bear Lake, Idaho.

Return to top

Cyrena
DUSTIN
Almira
MERRILL
Lucy Ann MERRILL
Philemon Christopher MERRILL
Samuel MERRILL
Seth Adelbert MERRILL
Phoebe ODELL

CHILDREN WITH CYRENA DUSTIN